From Click and Collect to Canine Crisis: How the UK Puppy Trade Is Failing Dogs, Vets, and the Planet
Nearly ten years ago, a DEFRA consultation openly acknowledged what many veterinary professionals already knew. The legislation governing the UK puppy trade was outdated, inflexible, and poorly aligned with modern welfare standards. Fast forward to today and the problem has not only persisted, it has scaled. A recent scoping review lays bare how systemic under-regulation has allowed the UK puppy trade to evolve into a high-volume, high-profit, and low-risk industry with profound consequences for canine welfare, public health, and the environment.
For vets on the front line, this is not an abstract policy issue. It shows up every day in consulting rooms, diagnostic labs, and emergency clinics.
Puppies as products in a digital marketplace
The modern puppy trade has been reshaped by consumer culture and the internet. Online marketplaces, social media platforms, and instant messaging apps have created an environment where sellers can remain anonymous, transactions are frictionless, and traceability is minimal. Puppies are increasingly purchased through a click-and-collect model that prioritises convenience and aesthetics over welfare and provenance. Demand surged dramatically during the COVID-19 pandemic and has remained high, fuelled by social media trends and influencer culture. Certain breeds and designer crossbreeds are marketed as lifestyle accessories rather than sentient animals. This demand incentivises rapid turnover, volume breeding, and cost cutting across the supply chain.
The review highlights how under-regulation enables systemic canine welfare issues. High-volume breeding operations often prioritise profit over health, resulting in inadequate socialisation, early weaning, poor maternal care, and limited veterinary oversight. These puppies are more likely to present with behavioural problems, infectious disease, and congenital conditions once they enter households. The emphasis on pedigree and designer crossbreeds compounds the issue. Many popular breeds are selected for exaggerated physical traits that are inherently linked to lifelong physiological disorders. As veterinary professionals, we see the downstream effects in the form of chronic respiratory disease, orthopaedic issues, dermatological conditions, and reduced quality of life.
One of the most troubling findings of the review is evidence of multi-level fraud and organised crime involvement within the puppy trade. Large-scale breeding operations reportedly smuggle puppies into the UK from countries endemic for diseases such as rabies and Leishmania. These puppies are often unvaccinated, inadequately documented, and sold through falsified paperwork. This creates a genuine public health concern. The introduction of zoonotic and vector-borne diseases threatens not only the domestic dog population but also veterinary staff and the wider public. The low perceived risk of enforcement allows these practices to continue largely unchecked.
The impact of the puppy trade does not stop at individual animals. The review draws attention to environmental consequences that are rarely part of the public conversation. High densities of pet dogs in urban areas contribute to significant faecal contamination, increasing the spread of anthelmintic-resistant and antibiotic-resistant pathogens. In addition, unsafe concentrations of ectoparasiticides have been detected in rivers and lakes. These chemicals, widely used in companion animal parasite control, can accumulate in aquatic environments with harmful effects on invertebrates and ecosystems. The scale of dog ownership driven by an unregulated market amplifies this environmental burden.
Why this matters to veterinary professionals
Veterinary teams sit at the intersection of animal welfare, public health, and environmental stewardship. We diagnose the diseases, manage the behavioural fallout, and often have difficult conversations with owners who unknowingly bought into a broken system. This scoping review provides a consolidated evidence base that validates what many in the profession have been observing for years. Importantly, it also positions veterinary professionals as key stakeholders in the push for meaningful reform. Improved regulation, enforcement, and transparency across the puppy trade are not just ethical imperatives. They are essential for safeguarding animal health, protecting public health, and reducing environmental harm.
The review calls for comprehensive regulatory reform that reflects the realities of a digital marketplace and modern consumer behaviour. This includes better licensing systems, improved traceability, stronger enforcement, and collaboration across animal welfare, public health, and environmental sectors. For millennial vets navigating a profession that increasingly values advocacy alongside clinical skill, this is an opportunity to influence change. Whether through client education, reporting concerns, supporting welfare organisations, or engaging in policy discussions, veterinary voices matter.
The UK puppy trade is not just a welfare issue. It is a complex, interconnected problem that touches every corner of veterinary practice. Ignoring it is no longer an option.
To read the original article: Click Here
